Does anyone else hate "Enable Copy/Cut Line without selection"?
-
@Alan-Kilborn said in Does anyone else hate "Enable Copy/Cut Line without selection"?:
If this bug doesn’t get fixed soon, perhaps I’ll subclass Search results and listen for WM_KEYDOWN with Ctrl+c, and do my own copy-to-clipboard.
Not tested at this point, but I don’t think that will work. The message loop gets keyboard input first; before it even dispatches it to the focused window, TranslateAccelerator will recognize it as an accelerator for a disabled menu command and it won’t propagate any further.
I can guess that the reason it hasn’t been fixed yet is that it’s non-trivial to fix it without mucking about in places where it’s likely to cause something else to go wrong. Making Ctrl+C/X/V application-level accelerators made a lot of things more complicated. Hindsight makes one wish the desired changes to cut/copy/paste function had been accomplished by subclassing the Scintilla edit controls instead… but I doubt that choice will be reconsidered now.
-
@Alan-Kilborn said in Does anyone else hate "Enable Copy/Cut Line without selection"?:
t boggles my mind that no one has the same problem I do – fat fingering Ctrl+c when trying to hit Ctrl+v.
Yes, I have the same fat fingering problem. Often I want to hit Ctrl+C but press Ctrl+V which is even worse :-)
-
This topics looks more like a complaint topic to put into Boycott Notepad++.
And Alan, you are a skilled programmer from what I saw until now. Why don’t you create a PR instead of complaining? ;-)
-
@MarkusBodensee said:
looks more like a complaint topic to put into Boycott Notepad++
Hardly.
Why don’t you create a PR instead
No way am I going to try to un-mess the whole debacle, as mentioned by @Coises .
I’m more likely to write the script I mentioned to work around the problem. -
@Alan-Kilborn said:
Hardly.
Sorry… but using the word “hate” in your post is a clear indication that it would be right over there.
-
@datatraveller1 said in Does anyone else hate "Enable Copy/Cut Line without selection"?:
Often I want to hit Ctrl+C but press Ctrl+V which is even worse
Oddly, I don’t seem to be plagued by that variant.
Actually, I don’t think that is worse because you can usually Ctrl+z undo it.
There is no undo for destroying the clipboard content (by trying to do Ctrl+v and mistakenly doing Ctrl+c). -
@Alan-Kilborn Yes, but the issue with my variant is that I think I have copied something but actually cut it, and sometimes even don’t notice that it was cut and not copied so the cut content is lost e.g. from a database field. However, my issue is not a Notepad++ issue, it is a general MS Windows fat fingering problem.
But thinking again of your variant - I am also plagued by your variant, so you are not the only one :-)
-
@Alan-Kilborn said in Does anyone else hate "Enable Copy/Cut Line without selection"?:
un-mess the whole debacle
Would it be less obnoxious if Edit | Copy and Cut were never disabled on the menu; that is, even when Enable Copy/Cut Line without selection is unchecked and nothing is selected, they would still be enabled: they just wouldn’t do anything?
If I understand the code correctly, that would be an easy “fix” that wouldn’t be likely to cause unexpected side-effects.
Edit to add: The next least complicated way I can think of to fix this would be to create a “proxy” command that doesn’t appear on the menu, to which Ctrl+C/Ctrl+Insert can attached as a keyboard accelerator. Unlike the command that appears on the menu, the proxy command would never be disabled, allowing WM_COPY to be passed on to whatever control has focus. The same should be done for Ctrl+X/Shift+Delete, assuming I am correct that this also affects some docking dialogs (which I still haven’t verified).
-
@Alan-Kilborn said in Does anyone else hate "Enable Copy/Cut Line without selection"?:
There is no undo for destroying the clipboard content (by trying to do Ctrl+v and mistakenly doing Ctrl+c).
I would have thought that Edit > Clipboard History would allow an undo for Ctrl+C – or that an external Clipboard-history tool would have that (and I thought you recently mentioned that you used one of those external clipboard tools when it came up in another discussion).
(Yes, E>CH isn’t a solution if you didn’t already have that panel open… but I would think the external clipboard tools were always running)
-
@PeterJones said:
and I thought you recently mentioned that you used one of those external clipboard tools when it came up in another discussion
I do, but it is a pain to have to go there to get data, when I just had it. :-)
-
@Coises said :
Would it be less obnoxious if Edit | Copy and Cut were never disabled on the menu; that is, even when Enable Copy/Cut Line without selection is unchecked and nothing is selected, they would still be enabled: they just wouldn’t do anything? If I understand the code correctly, that would be an easy “fix” that wouldn’t be likely to cause unexpected side-effects.
I don’t like it that much but…If it fixes the larger problem it’s an acceptable trade-off.
The next least complicated way I can think of to fix this would be to create a “proxy” command that doesn’t appear on the menu, to which Ctrl+C/Ctrl+Insert can attached as a keyboard accelerator. Unlike the command that appears on the menu, the proxy command would never be disabled, allowing WM_COPY to be passed on to whatever control has focus. The same should be done for Ctrl+X/Shift+Delete, assuming I am correct that this also affects some docking dialogs (which I still haven’t verified).
I do like this better as a N++ user, because I don’t see it. But it probably complicates the code too much to be accepted.
Anyway @Coises, if you want to get involved and try to fix this, you’d have my thanks.
-
It appears a fix for Ctrl+c being broken in Search results has just been PUBLISHED, so hopefully future discussion on this is moot.
-
I had forgotten that some else has the same fat fingers that I do, and thus shared my pain; it’s a bit of a rant, but some good reading: https://github.com/notepad-plus-plus/notepad-plus-plus/issues/15480
