Open Notepad++ via command line with a certain character set

whitecat

indeed, this solves my specific problem. Thank you for this hint. I had to modify my script though, now the logfile gets written into a file with a special extension (.log850) which I configured in the plugin.

But the general problem remains - what to do with files from applications with given extensions? I would consider such a command line option as very useful.

Alan Kilborn

@whitecat said in Open Notepad++ via command line with a certain character set:

But the general problem remains … I would consider such a command line option as very useful.

How would you envision such a command line syntax?

notepad++ yourfile.ext -charset="OEM 850"

datatraveller1

I would find this option which could be named
-charset or maybe more “mordern” -encoding
also very useful, so I upvoted your Github issue #8082

whitecat

@datatraveller1
@Alan-Kilborn

Notepad++ is capable of opening several files at once via command line, so the syntax could be enhanced in order to support opening different files with different charsets:

notepad++ yourfile1.ext -charset="OEM 850" yourfile2.ext -charset="UTF-8 BOM"

(or similar).

Alan Kilborn

@whitecat said in Open Notepad++ via command line with a certain character set:

notepad++ yourfile1.ext -charset=“OEM 850” yourfile2.ext -charset=“UTF-8 BOM”

That syntax feels “not quite right”.

Given the current possible command line is defined like this:

notepad++ [–help] [-multiInst] [-noPlugin] [-lLanguage] [-udl=“My UDL Name”] [-LlangCode] [-nLineNumber] [-cColumnNumber] [-pPosition] [-xLeftPos] [-yTopPos] [-monitor] [-nosession] [-notabbar] [-ro] [-systemtray] [-loadingTime] [-alwaysOnTop] [-openSession] [-r] [-qn=“Easter egg name” | -qt=“a text to display.” | -qf=“D:\my quote.txt”] [-qSpeed1|2|3] [-quickPrint] [-settingsDir=“d:\your settings dir”] [-openFoldersAsWorkspace] [-titleAdd=“additional title bar text”][filePath]

See how filePath is the last thing, and things BEFORE it affect it, e.g. -nLineNumber?

IMO, it makes more sense to have your proposed command line work as follows:

notepad++ yourfile1.ext -charset="OEM 850" yourfile2.ext -charset="UTF-8 BOM" yourfile3.ext yourfile4.ext

yourfile1.ext would not be affected by any -charset influence
yourfile2.ext would be opened and its encoding set to OEM 850
yourfile3.ext would be opened and its encoding set to UTF-8 BOM
yourfile4.ext would be opened and its encoding set to UTF-8 BOM

whitecat

@Alan-Kilborn

Yepp - you’re right, this would be more consistent.

datatraveller1

I’m wondering who decides if this feature request is implemented? Is there a particular procedure for a feature request?

Alan Kilborn

@datatraveller1 said in Open Notepad++ via command line with a certain character set:

I’m wondering who decides if this feature request is implemented? Is there a particular procedure for a feature request?

So the feature request is now an “issue”, which means it can get developer attention. The main author of Notepad++ can work on it, which gives it about a 100% to be accepted into the codebase, when complete. Or, someone else can work on it, and even if they finish a nice implementation on it, there is no guarantee that the author will accept it into the codebase. Or…nothing will ever happen on it (there are a lot of open bug issues, and a lot of other feature request issues).

datatraveller1

@Alan-Kilborn ok, I understand. Thank you!

Alan Kilborn

Earlier I had said:

IMO, it makes more sense to have your proposed command line work as follows:

notepad++ yourfile1.ext -charset=“OEM 850” yourfile2.ext -charset=“UTF-8 BOM” yourfile3.ext yourfile4.txt

While that’s an idyllic command line, logically, it doesn’t really suit how Notepad++ currently works; example:

notepad++ -multiInst -n15 yourfile1.txt -n10 yourfile2.txt

While this will open “yourfile1.txt” at line 15, it will NOT open “yourfile2.txt” at line 10.

But this:

notepad++ -multiInst -n15 yourfile1.txt yourfile2.txt

will open both files at line 15.

So I think it is reasonable to allow only one -charset=... on a command line, that affects all following files; example:

notepad++ yourfile1.ext -charset="UTF-8 BOM" yourfile3.ext yourfile4.txt <-- contains only ONE charset directive.

If a second -charset is encountered on the command-line, it would be ignored.