select language by name and not by extension

Alan Kilborn

@franco-otaola said in select language by name and not by extension:

I know that is a strange question,

Not really all that strange…

An idea would be to use PythonScript and set up a buffer-activated notification callback. When the notification fires, check the filename of the active buffer against your criteria; if there’s a match then set the language appropriately.

Something like this for the callback:

def bufferactivated_callback(args):
    pathname = notepad.getCurrentFilename()
    if not pathname.startswith('new'):
        filename = pathname.rsplit(os.sep, 1)[-1]
        ext = filename.rsplit('.', 1)[-1]
        if ext == filename:
            # no extension
            notepad.setLangType(LANGTYPE.CPP)

This doesn’t cover all the cases, e.g., saving a “new” file with an extensionless name won’t automatically do it, but some other code that is similar could be written to cover those type of things.

franco otaola

hello, thanks for your kindly (and complete) answers :)
On samll question from your answer @PeterJones , is it possible to add more of this recognized first line?
as this will solve my issue directly.
as all the files that use shell scritp have “#!/bin/bash” in the first line, (it is not regognized as #!/usr/bin/bash as you mentioned) and the other files always begings with
“/--------------------------------- C++ -----------------------------------”
this would solve completly my issue and without the need of any extra steps when opening the files
thanks!

franco otaola

@franco-otaola One thing it should be noted, is that even if I add #!/usr/bin/bash to the first line notepad ++ does not recognize that is shell script, maybe there is an option that is not active?

Alan Kilborn

@franco-otaola said in select language by name and not by extension:

is it possible to add more of this recognized first line?

No, not if that is the only thing you do. If you’ll note, Peter said:

a few of the lexers have a few “extras” hardcoded into either the lexer’s source code or into the main Notepad++ source code

“Hardcoded” means just that. “A few” means just that.

That being said you can certain script something to do this new requirement. In fact it will look a lot like the script already shown, except with an additional condition. Maybe that condition is something like:

...
matches = []
editor.research(r'^\Q/--------------------------------- C++ -----------------------------------', lambda m: matches.append(m.span(0)), 0, 100, 1)
if len(matches) == 1:
    notepad.setLangType(LANGTYPE.CPP)

PeterJones

@franco-otaola said in select language by name and not by extension:

@franco-otaola One thing it should be noted, is that even if I add #!/usr/bin/bash to the first line notepad ++ does not recognize that is shell script, maybe there is an option that is not active?

I cannot replicate:

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>echo #!/bin/bash > bb & type bb
#!/bin/bash

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>echo #!/usr/bin/bash > ubb & type ubb
#!/usr/bin/bash

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>echo #!bash > justb & type justb
#!bash

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>echo #!perl > justp & type justp
#!perl

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>notepad++ bb ubb justb justp

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>echo #! a bunch of other stuff then bash then more stuff > otherb & type otherb
#! a bunch of other stuff then bash then more stuff

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>notepad++ otherb

file	screenshot
bb
ubb
justb
justp
otherb

Those screenshots show what Notepad++ shows those files like immediately when I open them, with no special processing on my part. (*) The exact path on the shebang line shouldn’t matter. As long as Notepad++ (or the lexer; I haven’t searched for the shebang recognition code location) sees the first line start with shebang and contain the keyword (like bash for unix script files or perl for perl files) , it should “just work”.

*: I ran the experiment: I unzipped a fresh portable v8.3.3, separate from my normal installation, with no customizations or additional plugins beyond the default. The behavior is the same: they were all automatically recognized as Unix script files or Perl source file. So if your installed Notepad++ is not recognizing a file starting with #!/bin/bash , try the same experiment: download a portable zip; uzip; open your example file with that portable Notepad++. It should auto-detect.

If it doesn’t autodetect, then I’m guessing you have something like mixed line endings (so some lines with CRLF and others with just LF, which might confuse the auto-detector if the first line doesn’t match the auto-detected), or that you have a BOM sequence U+FEFF (which is encoded as the three bytes 0xEF 0xBB 0xBF in a UTF-8 file, or 0xFF 0xFE in a UTF-16-LE, or 0xFE 0xFF in UTF-16-BE…
Nope, I even created a file that has the UTF8 BOM sequence,

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>xxd u8.txt
00000000: efbb bf23 212f 6269 6e2f 6261 7368       ...#!/bin/bash

And it still autodetects as a Unix script file:

Ah, there we go: if I create a UTF-16 LE or BE file, Notepad++ does not auto-detect those.

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>xxd u16be.txt
00000000: feff 0023 0021 002f 0062 0069 006e 002f  ...#.!./.b.i.n./
00000010: 0062 0061 0073 0068                      .b.a.s.h

C:\Users\peter.jones\Downloads\TempData\nppCommunity>xxd u16le.txt
00000000: fffe 2300 2100 2f00 6200 6900 6e00 2f00  ..#.!./.b.i.n./.
00000010: 6200 6100 7300 6800                      b.a.s.h.

(I think I got xxd with a copy of gvim for windows at some point; since I would never recommend any text editor but Notepad++, you can also download it here; or you can get od and a bunch of other gnu/linux-like utilities here, where od -A x -x filename can give similar information)

So at this point, my theory is that you’re either in a UTF-16 encoding, or you have mixed line endings. Without screenshots showing the full Notepad++ window including the status bar with enough width for the status bar to show all the pertinent information, and without a ?-menu Debug Info > Copy debug info into clipboard pasted here, there isn’t much more guessing that we can do as to why the shebang recognition isn’t working for you.

Michael Vincent

@peterjones said in select language by name and not by extension:

(I think I got xxd

Just FYI, xxd is distributed with Git for Windows:

PS VinsWorldcom ~ > which xxd
C:\usr\bin\git\usr\bin\xxd.exe

Cheers.

franco otaola

Hello peter,
I am sorry if I am being ignorant but I still get this behavior with my file (here is the link to the text file: https://we.tl/t-P4HLQudxXi)
but I think understand where it comes from!
actually, the issue begins to show when I select a default language over preferences/new document.
once I have this option active, the “recognition” of the #!/bin/bash disappears. it overwrites
(as I had these two types of files that do not have extensions, it was a solution to use the default for everything C++ as the shell would be recognized.
sorry for the trouble.
and thanks for the help

franco otaola

it looks like the order of importance is the following (in the choice of language):

extension of the file
default language
first line e.g. #!/bin/bash
(which in my logic it was 1. then 3. and lastly 2.)

PeterJones

@franco-otaola said in select language by name and not by extension:

default language

Interesting, I was going to disagree, because I believed that the default language only applied to files created by File > New or equivalent. But I ran the quick experiment, and you are correct: if you have a Default Language set to anything but None (Normal Text), then it doesn’t apply the shebang or <?xml?> heuristics. Interesting.

I would agree that the way it is runs counter to expectations. I think I will submit that as a bug report / feature improvement.

PeterJones

@peterjones said in select language by name and not by extension:

I think I will submit that as a bug report / feature improvement.

Priority order on heuristic: https://github.com/notepad-plus-plus/notepad-plus-plus/issues/11504

UTF-16 BE/LE ignores heuristic: https://github.com/notepad-plus-plus/notepad-plus-plus/issues/11505