PeterJones has a good test for this, and I would add one more thing to check first: how you close Notepad++ after removing the tabs. If you close the window with the X button, Notepad++ should save the session on exit, but if the program is still running in the background, for example after closing the window while it is minimized to the tray, or if a second instance is open, the older session can be written back over the newer one. Try closing with File > Exit after removing the tabs, then check whether the files stay closed on the next launch. It is also worth checking Settings > Backup to see whether Periodic Backup is on, since that is separate from the session list and can bring back the contents of unsaved notes even when the tabs themselves are gone.